The Buckeye Weekly Podcast podcast

Why Won't Ohio State Play Tavien St. Clair?

0:00
25:40
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds
Why isn't Tavien St. Clair playing quarterback for Ohio State? Why did Jeremiah Smith go nearly half a game without touching the football? And what does Ryan Day plan to do about the Buckeyes' struggling defense and special teams?

Following Ohio State's third loss of the season, Ryan Day met with reporters on Tuesday to address the growing list of problems facing his football program.

In this episode of the Buckeye Weekly Podcast, Tony Gerdeman and Tom Orr break down Day's comments and discuss what they reveal about Ohio State's plans heading into Saturday's game against Northwestern.

Day confirmed that Luke Fahey will remain Ohio State's starting quarterback, despite increasing calls from fans to give true freshman Tavien St. Clair an opportunity. Tony and Tom explain why the coaching staff apparently isn't ready to make that move and what St. Clair would need to show in practice to earn meaningful playing time.

They also examine the puzzling lack of involvement for Jeremiah Smith against Oregon. How does the nation's best receiver go two quarters without a target? And why doesn't Ohio State simply design more plays specifically to get him the football?

On defense, Ryan Day acknowledged that he remains heavily involved in game-planning discussions with Matt Patricia. That raises another question: If Day wants an aggressive defense, why are the Buckeyes continuing to play so conservatively?

Finally, Tony and Tom discuss the firing of special teams coordinator Robby Discher, the disastrous fake punt against Oregon, and whether additional coaching changes could be coming.

00:00 – Welcome to Buckeye Weekly: Breaking down Ryan Day's latest press conference
00:33 – Ryan Day confirms Luke Fahey will start against Northwestern
01:29 – Why Tavien St. Clair isn't getting an opportunity at quarterback
02:30 – What Ohio State's coaches need to see from St. Clair in practice
04:02 – Could Ohio State simplify the offense to get St. Clair on the field?
05:00 – Why Luke Fahey remains the Buckeyes' best option for now
05:41 – Why did Jeremiah Smith go nearly two quarters without touching the football?
07:15 – Ohio State's limited possessions and the failure to target Smith
08:45 – Why Ohio State needs to make Jeremiah Smith the first read more often
09:52 – How Smith's presence creates opportunities for other receivers
10:39 – Why Jeremiah Smith sometimes comes off the field on third down
11:41 – Ryan Day's involvement in Matt Patricia's defensive game plans
12:46 – Why Day's desire for an aggressive defense doesn't match the results
13:22 – Defensive breakdowns, missed assignments, and recurring problems
15:21 – Ryan Day addresses the firing of special teams coordinator Robby Discher
15:36 – How Ohio State will divide special teams coaching responsibilities
16:35 – Will firing Discher actually improve Ohio State's special teams?
17:03 – The fake punt against Oregon and Ohio State's lack of special teams creativity
18:17 – Does Ryan Day need to take a more aggressive approach on special teams?
18:43 – Why Ohio State isn't firing more assistant coaches right now
20:15 – Why Ryan Day isn't ready to play younger players simply to evaluate them
21:55 – How Ohio State's situation differs from Michigan's coaching changes
23:11 – Final takeaways from Ryan Day's press conference
23:24 – Viewer questions, Buckeye Insiders, and final thoughts

Join Buckeye Insiders!

Get exclusive Ohio State football coverage, insider reporting, recruiting analysis, premium message board discussions, and more at:
https://BuckeyeInsiders.com

Join Tony Gerdeman, Tom Orr, and the Buckeye Insiders community for daily coverage and conversation about everything happening with Ohio State football.

Watch more Ohio State coverage on YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/@BuckeyeInsiders

Join the conversation!

More episodes from "The Buckeye Weekly Podcast"