Best of Joe Rose Show: Nov. 17-21

Wednesday’s show kicks off with the Panthers scoring five first-period goals in a win over the Sens and the Marlins cruising past the White Sox, while Alex Ovechkin continues to defy age with another multi-goal night. Joe dives into Dolphins talk as Jeff Hafley shares his old-school approach to accountability and time management, sparking a discussion about today’s player culture. Omar Kelly breaks down the new “Green Bay South” direction for the Dolphins under Jon-Eric Sullivan and Hafley, while Channing Crowder pushes back on claims that Miami’s party culture holds the team back, emphasizing that talent wins. Marc Ross weighs in on the quarterback landscape and Malik Willis’ limited NFL sample size, explaining how teams evaluate prospects through combines, workouts, and game tape. The show wraps with Dolphins draft strategy, potential interest in Ty Simpson, and reactions to Jason Taylor’s comments that Pro Days are just a “pageant,” highlighting what really matters for building a winning roster.

Hour 1 kicks off with a strong night in South Florida as the Florida Panthers explode for five first-period goals and the Miami Marlins cruise past the Chicago White Sox, while Alex Ovechkin continues to defy age with another multi-goal performance. That sparks a conversation about old-school vs new-school. We then shift to the Miami Dolphins, where Jeff Hafley brings an old-school message of accountability, leading into a discussion about today’s player culture and young leaders like Malachi Toney. Joe also breaks down what to expect from Malik Willis this season, the holes across Miami’s roster, and why this upcoming draft will be critical for the franchise’s rebuild.

Hour 2 features Omar Kelly joining the show to break down the new “Green Bay South” direction of the Miami Dolphins under Jon-Eric Sullivan and Jeff Hafley, highlighting the need for more alpha personalities and what to expect from Malik Willis. The conversation sparks debate as Joe pushes back on the idea that Miami’s off-field distractions are the issue, pointing instead to a lack of talent on the roster. We also touch on the Miami Marlins picking up a win over the Chicago White Sox and look ahead to the rubber match. Plus, Hollywood’s Headlines covers everything from Shohei Ohtani dealing on the mound to LIV vs. PGA debates ahead of The Masters, along with updates on Tiger Woods and a major moon launch out of Florida.

Hour 3 features Joe Zagacki, the voice of the Miami Hurricanes, recapping last season’s incredible run to the national championship and highlighting the players, leadership, and work ethic that drove their success. He pivots to looking ahead, discussing challenges like replacing much of the offensive line, evaluating this year’s pass rushers under Jason Taylor, and spotlighting key players such as Darian Mensah, Malachi Toney, and Mark Fletcher. The conversation then shifts to the Dolphins as Channing Crowder joins to push back on claims that Miami’s party culture hinders the team, emphasizing that talent wins and sharing examples from his own playing days. Finally, Marc Ross weighs in on the quarterback landscape, analyzing Malik Willis’ limited sample size, the remaining NFL QB market, and how teams evaluate prospects through workouts, combines, and live game tape, offering a complete look at what matters most for projecting future success.

Hour 4 briefly touches on Miami’s wins as the Marlins and Panthers both came out on top last night, then shifts to Dolphins discussion. Joe and Hollywood break down draft strategy, potential interest in Ty Simpson, and how Miami’s off-field distractions affect the team, reacting to Jason Taylor’s comments that Pro Days are just a “pageant” and what really matters is performance in actual games. The hour wraps with a look at the Dolphins offseason and how the “Green Bay guys” are rebuilding the Dolphins roster.

Omar Kelly joins the show as Joe credits him for coining the term “Green Bay South” to describe the new Miami Dolphins regime led by Jon-Eric Sullivan and Jeff Hafley. Omar reflects on past Dolphins regimes, the different approaches they’ve taken, and the unique off-field distractions that come with playing in Miami. He emphasizes the need for more alpha personalities in the locker room, something the team has lacked, while also weighing in on Hafley’s comments about Chop Robinson. Omar also breaks down what to expect from Malik Willis, noting the Dolphins will lean into his mobility and athleticism, with Hafley prioritizing dynamic quarterbacks moving forward.

Channing Crowder joins the show to push back on Omar Kelly’s claim that Miami’s party culture is hurting the Dolphins. Crowder insists that off-field fun has nothing to do with success, emphasizing that “talent wins.” He shares examples from his own college days at UF, where he partied hard yet still earned All-SEC and All-American honors, and highlights other Dolphins players who enjoyed Miami nightlife but still performed at a high level on the field.

Joe Zagacki, the voice of the Miami Hurricanes, recaps the Canes’ incredible run to last season’s national championship, highlighting the key contributors and moments that defined their success. He then pivots to looking ahead to this season, discussing the challenges of replacing much of the offensive line and evaluating the Hurricanes’ pass rushers under Jason Taylor, comparing them to last year’s stars Bain and Mesidor, who are now heading to the NFL. Zagacki shares insights on key players like Darian Mensah and Malachi Toney, including Toney’s leadership and relentless work ethic. He also breaks down Mark Fletcher’s development and the impact of early-enrolled recruits who contributed during last year’s playoff run, setting the stage for another strong season.

Marc Ross joins to break down the quarterback landscape in the upcoming NFL Draft, weighing in on the remaining options as teams await Aaron Rodgers’ decision with the Steelers. He critiques how some organizations, including the Dolphins, have handled player background evaluations and shares concerns about Malik Willis’ limited NFL experience. Ross also dives into how teams balance offseason workouts, pro days, and combine performances against actual game tape when evaluating prospects, offering insight into what really matters when projecting a quarterback’s potential.

Joe breaks down what the season could look like with Malik Willis under center, emphasizing the need for the Miami Dolphins to surround him with more help on offense. He points out the many holes on the roster, including pass rusher, and the importance of a bounce-back year from Chop Robinson under Jeff Hafley. With a young roster, a first-year head coach, and much of the payroll tied up in dead money, expectations are tempered for this season. That makes the upcoming draft absolutely critical as Miami looks to add foundational pieces for the future.