Hour 3: Joe B. on the Jets | What do NY fans root for in Week 18?

Francisco Lindor heard plenty of criticism after his two gaffes in the Mets' series finale against the Cardinals, to the point where Craig Carton called for his tenure in Queens to come to an end. Plus, Evan Roberts says Carlos Mendoza missed an opportunity to send a message and bench the veteran shortstop, and Gregg Giannotti believes the fanbase needs to calm down.

Cam Schlittler was all the hype this week in Yankees Universe, as Evan Roberts declares that the sky is the limit for the Yankee righty, and Gio says Schlittler would fit right in on the 90s dynasty teams. Plus, Tommy Lugauer says Max Fried was worth every penny, Evan and Tiki see a new edge to these Yanks, and Boomer and Gio react to the Bombers' success with the new ABS challenge system.

Opening Day at Yankee Stadium brings optimism, energy, and a noticeably different tone around a Yankees team that looks locked in from the start. With a strong 5-1 opening stretch and dominant pitching leading the way, there is a growing sense that this season carries more urgency and purpose than years past. At the same time, concern is building across town as the Mets stumble out of the gate with sloppy play and lack of execution. The conversation dives into whether it is just early season noise or signs of deeper issues, including leadership questions and mounting pressure on the manager as frustration begins to grow among fans.

A heated debate erupts over whether fans should boo Jack Hughes at Yankee Stadium, even as he represents Team USA. The conversation dives into the tension between team loyalty and national pride, sparking strong reactions from fans and hosts alike. What does it really mean to be a diehard fan, and where should the line be drawn? Beyond the Hughes controversy, the show breaks down early season overreactions from both Yankees and Mets fans. From concerns about slumping performances to debates over player development and expectations, the discussion captures the emotional rollercoaster of April baseball. It is a mix of passion, perspective, and plenty of classic fan logic.

Opening Day energy is in full swing, and the Yankees are already giving fans plenty to be excited about. From dominant early pitching performances to a clubhouse fueled by urgency, this episode dives into why this team feels different and what it could mean for the season ahead. With insight from David Cone and David Bednar, the conversation explores rising arms like Will Warren, the evolution of young talent, and the impact of leadership from veterans like Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. Plus, a look at the ABS challenge system, bullpen concerns, and whether this team truly has the edge to turn early promise into something special.

Evan and Tiki are live from Yankee Stadium for the Home Opener. They break down the Yanks' hot start, the Mets troubles, David Cone and David Bednar join the show, and much more.

As the show rolls into the final stretch from Yankee Stadium, the focus shifts from analysis to atmosphere. The energy of Opening Day takes over, blending baseball talk with the kind of unpredictable, in-the-moment reactions that make live shows memorable. From fan behavior debates to unforgettable food discoveries and classic back and forth between the hosts, the conversation leans into the full stadium experience. It is a mix of humor, strong opinions, and authentic reactions that capture what it feels like to be at the ballpark when the season officially comes alive.

Opening Day at Yankee Stadium brings a different kind of energy, and the early signs point to a team playing with purpose. From a hot start fueled by pitching to a clubhouse carrying a chip on its shoulder, the conversation centers on why this version of the Yankees feels locked in from the jump. With David Cone breaking down the evolution of the rotation and David Bednar sharing a player’s perspective from inside the clubhouse, the discussion highlights emerging arms, improved command, and the mindset driving this group. Add in thoughts on leadership, preparation, and new elements like the ABS challenge system, and it paints a clear picture of a team determined to turn early momentum into something meaningful.

With the season barely underway, frustration is already boiling over for Mets fans as concerns about roster construction and early struggles take center stage. The conversation questions whether this team has real upside or if fans are watching a flawed blueprint play out in real time, creating tension between patience and panic. The discussion also shifts to the Yankees, where expectations around young players like Anthony Volpe are being recalibrated. From debates about earning playing time to the dangers of early season overreactions, the final stretch of the show blends sharp analysis with fan emotion as both teams face very different, but equally intense, scrutiny.

A simple first pitch turns into a full blown debate as the question of booing Jack Hughes lights up the show. With emotions tied to both Team USA pride and deep rooted Rangers Devils rivalry, the discussion quickly escalates into a passionate clash over what true fandom looks like. Is loyalty to your team absolute, or are there moments that rise above it? The conversation brings strong reactions from across the room, with arguments ranging from Olympic hero respect to the reality of hockey rivalries that never sleep. As opinions fly and lines are drawn, the debate becomes less about one player and more about the identity of a fan, and how far that allegiance should go.