
We Bullied Andrew Into Eating Cottage Cheese and It Did Not Go Well
2/18/2026
0:00
9:26
What started as a harmless food debate turned into peer pressure, gagging, shaking hands, and a near-vomit situation. Andrew finally tries cottage cheese for the first time, immediately regrets it, and absolutely ruins any chance of charity donations. Along the way, the group debates spoiled milk textures, foods that should be illegal, and why some dislikes are simply hard-wired into your soul. Warning: lots of yelling, zero mercy, and one very traumatized coworker.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
More episodes from "Elvis Duran's After Party"



Don't miss an episode of “Elvis Duran's After Party” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








