Fork U with Dr. Terry Simpson podcast

Diet Disappointment 2024 Version

0:00
12:11
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Sorry It Didn't Work

This is the time of year when everyone is excited about some change in their life. My neighbors are doing a "dry January" because they want to cut down on their alcohol. Other neighbors committed to more physical activity before a hip replacement. And there is the inevitable "what diet will I do this time?"

Now, before I go to that, long-time readers of my newsletter will realize that I am drinking my cup of Peet's coffee. Peet's is a story of disappointment, which I will use to illustrate a point:

Diet Disappointment

Diets are like that person who disappoints you again and again. The person you invite to events, but they never reciprocate. The diet starts out great. You lose a bit of weight, decide you can eat this way forever, and this is your new lifestyle. Then something happens. If you are smart, you realize you cannot live that way. Most, though, internalize and think, "It is my fault." Well, it isn't your fault.

Low Carb Disappointment

Low-carb diets can be disappointing for various reasons. Some people may find it difficult to stick to a low-carb eating plan because they miss certain high-carb foods that they enjoy. This can lead to feelings of deprivation and dissatisfaction with the diet. Additionally, some people may not experience the weight loss or health benefits they were hoping for with a low-carb diet. It's important to remember that everyone's body is different, and what works for one person may not work for another. Furthermore, it is important to focus on overall health and well-being rather than just weight loss or specific dietary restrictions.

Every year, someone starts a new version of low carb. I've done a few myself. This year's version is carnivore. Some are doing a carnivore January. The results will be the same as the previous low-carb diets - and let me go back to Peet's coffee.

Coffee and Diets

I have been a member of Peet's Coffee Club since 1995. I get it faithfully every couple of weeks. Whole beans. It costs about $36 for two bags. Then I discovered I could get it at Costco for $25, with no shipping charge, the same date of roasting. I wrote Peet's, of course. They told me my coffee is always fresh, unlike the bulk sold to Costco. Except the roasting date is on the package.

Diets are like that. You get some results, then disappointment. You don't get the return for the money. But someone in the low-carb community will tell you that you didn't do it correctly:

  • You were not earnest enough,
  • You didn't get the right kind of grass-fed beef
  • The beef wasn't organic
  • You ate a banana and ruined ketosis
  • If you stop eating carrots, you will maintain ketosis.
  • Oh, does that pasta look delicious
  • Stop eating vegetables and grains, and just eat beef, salt, and water

Now What?

So, some consider weight loss surgery or new drugs. Both of these are reasonable (yes, I have done a lot of weight loss surgery in my time).

But what I've advocated is that people have to take responsibility for what they eat even after weight loss surgery. Well, you don't have to - but your body is a perfect calorie counter.

Does that mean a "diet?" No, the goal of weight loss drugs or surgery isn't to put someone on a diet for weight loss. The goal is to give them good food so they can nourish themselves.

It also means I have to get rid of silly ideas they learned from things like the low-carb diet. The low-carb diet, that friend you always invite into your home, always disappoints.

My Journey to Culinary Medicine

About ten years ago, I received certification in Culinary Medicine. Part of that training was long hours reviewing the literature...

More episodes from "Fork U with Dr. Terry Simpson"