The Amazing Race Rewind

Andrew Penner & Jill Kolodka

Join us every Wednesday as we rewind back in time to the earliest seasons of The Amazing Race! We discuss the show weekly on an episode-by-episode basis from the perspective of two fans watching these seasons for the first time.

It is recommended to watch the episodes along with us for the best listening experience!

You can email us any questions, comments, or suggestions at [email protected]!

70 Episodes

The Amazing Race Season 5 Deep Dive
11/7/2026
1:30:58
We are back with our seasonly deep dive! We discuss why we think the season is overhyped, the cruciality of season 5's success for the franchise, post-race and BTS info, what the season did/didn't do well, and what we hope to see for season 6!**Note that this was recorded several months ago -Send us an email at [email protected]! -Follow us on instagram @amazingracerewind!
S05E12 (Finale: part 2) - You just made me a millionaire
3/13/2026
50:26
In this finale episode, we discuss the race's first visit to Canada, how a team lucked into their win, compare this finale to seasons past, and much more! -Send us an email at [email protected] -Follow us on Instagram @amazingracerewind!
Don't miss an episode of “The Amazing Race Rewind” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.
S05E12 (Finale: Part 1) - Now it's Kim time
3/4/2026
35:18
In this episode, we discuss the first hour of the season 5 finale, including a gorgeous visit to El Nido, flag confusion, and the elimination that determines the final three teams. -Send us an email at [email protected]! -Follow us on Instagram @amazingracerewind!
S05E11 - It's not just that they suck, it's that we're decent (with Jamie)
2/25/2026
1:03:32
In this episode, we are delighted to welcome first time guest Jamie!! She is our resident guide to the Philippines as we discuss crashouts, coconuts, carabao and so much more!-Follow us on Instagram @amazingracerewind!-Send us an email at [email protected]!
S05E10 - Thank god .... literally
2/11/2026
36:41
In this episode, we discuss The Amazing Race's second trip to New Zealand, including the most fun tasks we've seen, the failure of the non-elimination twist, and the demise of a favourite team. -Follow us on Instagram @amazingracerewind! -Send us an email at [email protected]!
S05E09 - We are sooo gonna manipulate people
2/4/2026
35:36
In this episode, we discuss a classic old school India leg, including a controversial fast forward, a great roadblock, a flop detour, and much more!
S5E08 - Gastronomic Gauntlet
1/28/2026
33:52
In this episode we get a look into the teams' money problems, flat tires, a close call with prison, and much more!-Follow us on Instagram @amazingracerewind!-Send us an email at [email protected]!
S05E07 - Don't help these Americans, they're violent (with Kyla and Hudson)
1/21/2026
59:33
In this episode, we welcome back Kyla as a guest and introduce Hudson, a first-time guest. We discuss the final six teams, an all-time airport drama sequence, a shocking elimination, and much more!-Follow us on Instagram @amazingracerewind! -Send us an email at [email protected]!
S05E06 - Egyptology 101
1/14/2026
49:32
In this episode we hear about Andrew's crazy conspiracies, Jill's philosophical musings, hustle a herd of animals, and much more!Stay tuned for, not one, but TWO exciting guests next week!-Follow us on Instagram @amazingracerewind!-Send us an email at [email protected]!
S05E05 - Bellissimo! (with Sarah)
12/31/2025
58:55
In this episode, we have our first guest of season 5 to discuss a leg that expertly balanced travel and tasks, rule changes, Egyptology, Charla and Mirna's language skills, and much more! -Follow us on Instagram @amazingracerewind! -Send us an email at [email protected]!

More Episodes

Get the whole world of podcasts with the free GetPodcast app.

Subscribe to your favorite podcasts, listen to episodes offline and get thrilling recommendations.

Privacy Policy
Imprint
United States

A company from

The Amazing Race Rewind

Andrew Penner & Jill Kolodka

70 Episodes

The Amazing Race Season 5 Deep Dive

S05E12 (Finale: part 2) - You just made me a millionaire

S05E12 (Finale: Part 1) - Now it's Kim time

S05E11 - It's not just that they suck, it's that we're decent (with Jamie)

S05E10 - Thank god .... literally

S05E09 - We are sooo gonna manipulate people

S5E08 - Gastronomic Gauntlet

S05E07 - Don't help these Americans, they're violent (with Kyla and Hudson)

S05E06 - Egyptology 101

S05E05 - Bellissimo! (with Sarah)