Welcome back to Save Your Money, Save Your Teeth. In the previous episode, Eon Engelbrecht and Dr Clifford Yudelman looked at 4D printing and shape memory aligners. This episode stays with clever materials, but turns to the ones that go inside the tooth itself: bioactive materials that release minerals, fight acid and claim to help a tooth protect itself.
They cover what "bioactive" really means, whether a filling can help a tooth heal, how MTA can protect a nerve and avoid a root canal, why the edges of a filling matter so much, and what is real versus marketing in "self-healing" fillings. They also discuss whether bioactive fillings last longer than ordinary white fillings, who benefits most from these materials, how they look compared with composite or porcelain, how they fit into a save-your-money approach, and the questions patients should ask their dentist, along with how these materials are used at OptiSmile.
10 Questions and Summary Answers
[1:18] What exactly is a bioactive material? Dr Yudelman explains that "bioactive" is a word marketing departments love and use loosely. Strictly speaking, it means a material that interacts with the tooth, releasing calcium, phosphate or fluoride and encouraging the tooth to respond. The top composite bonding materials used day to day at OptiSmile, such as G-ænial Universal Injectable, are not bioactive; they are valued for their strength, handling, wear resistance and the seal they form to enamel and dentine. Genuinely bioactive materials are a much smaller group, used mostly deep down near the nerve, underneath a normal composite. He warns that some biologic dentists place proprietary "natural mineral" materials, and that he has seen these fail badly, cracking and wearing, sometimes leading to root canals or tooth loss.
[5:36] Can a filling material actually help a tooth heal itself or even grow new dentine? Enamel never comes back, but the living tooth underneath can respond. Calcium silicate cements such as MTA, originally derived from Portland cement, can encourage the nerve to lay down a fresh bridge of hard tissue over itself, and even a nerve that bleeds during preparation can settle and heal under MTA. This only works on a healthy nerve; lingering pain to cold of more than 20 seconds or spontaneous pain points to a root canal instead. Modern guidelines also say the dentist does not need to scrape every last bit of soft decay off the nerve, as long as the edges are cleaned thoroughly and the tooth is properly sealed. Dr Yudelman describes the glass ionomer approach he uses, where decay sealed under glass ionomer in a symptom-free tooth was later shown to harden up.
[9:36] Why do the edges of a filling matter so much? Most fillings do not fail because they break; they fail because decay creeps back in at the edges. Glass ionomer releases fluoride when it is hit by acid, like a sprinkler that switches on when there is smoke, and actively fights decay. It is useful in the elderly, in root cavities, in children and where moisture is hard to control, and it is the basis of the ART technique used in countries with little access to care. Dr Yudelman does not generally use glass ionomer for permanent fillings in adults, as fillings he sees placed this way may not decay but wear badly and do not look good.
[11:10] Some materials claim to self-heal tiny gaps. What is real and what is marketing? According to the research, self-healing fillings are not real yet, although the idea is promising for the future. Dr Yudelman explains that a strong, solid, ceramic-like composite that bonds to the tooth cannot at the same time leach chemicals and deposit minerals. For now, patients should not worry about self-sealing fillings.
[11:57] Do bioactive fillings actually last longer than ordinary white fillings? No; this is where the marketing gets ahead of the evidence. Dr Yudelman notes that one well-known material sold as bioactive failed at about ten times the rate of an ordinary composite in a clinical trial. In a glass ionomer sandwich, he keeps the glass ionomer closest to the nerve and makes sure none is exposed at the edges, because it can wash out. Newer resin-modified glass ionomers are light cured and behave much like composites, but they release very little fluoride outside the laboratory.
[13:26] Who benefits most from these materials? Patients at very high risk of decay benefit most: older patients with decay on exposed roots, frail or nursing home patients where a sensitive tooth affects quality of life, and patients with no saliva after radiation treatment. Dr Yudelman likes glass ionomer for children because it bonds well, and wear matters less on baby teeth that will be lost anyway. He prefers glass ionomers to resin sealants, based on research he was exposed to by Professor Laurence Walsh in Australia. These materials have their place, but it is limited.
[15:18] Do they actually look as natural as white fillings or porcelain? Absolutely not. Glass ionomer has a very opaque look, although newer resin-modified versions are more translucent, and MTA is grey, almost black, so it must be well hidden under the filling. MTA is also very expensive, so these materials are placed close to the nerve and covered with composite or a ceramic inlay or onlay, with crowns avoided unless absolutely necessary. Many dentists use them along the gum line, where fillings are hard to keep in place, and Dr Yudelman suggests a future refresher episode on gum line fillings.
[16:49] They cost a little more. How do they fit into the save your money philosophy? Cheap dentistry that fails early is expensive dentistry; if an MTA pulp cap keeps a nerve alive and avoids a root canal and crown, it saves thousands of rands. Cochrane reviews found no proven benefit to placing these materials routinely under every ordinary composite, so patients who see a pulp cap on a quote can ask whether it is truly needed, since no one can check once it is under the filling. At OptiSmile, if a filling turns out deeper than expected and needs an unquoted pulp cap, it is normally done at no charge rather than upcharging after a quote. Where a pulp cap is quoted, the fee of just over a thousand rand reflects the extra time and care to remove decay carefully and avoid a root canal, not just the material.
[20:22] What should patients ask their dentist? Dr Yudelman suggests three questions. First, if the decay is deep, can the nerve be protected rather than removed with a root canal; if the dentist has not heard of MTA, a second opinion is worthwhile, especially if cold sensitivity fades within about ten seconds. Second, am I at high risk of decay, and would a fluoride-releasing material help, for example after radiation treatment or with dry mouth from Sjögren's syndrome. Third, if a bioactive filling is being sold as a premium upgrade or promoted on Instagram or TikTok, be sceptical.
[20:22] How are these materials used at OptiSmile? Most fillings at OptiSmile are ordinary, best-in-class composite that is well bonded to the tooth. If the nerve is exposed, it is capped with MTA. If the cavity is deep or the patient is at high risk, glass ionomer goes under the composite. Dr Yudelman sums it up by saying the smartest dentistry is the quiet dentistry that lasts.
Outro
The takeaway from this episode is that "bioactive" is more marketing term than miracle. Strong, well-bonded composite remains the workhorse filling, while genuinely active materials such as MTA and glass ionomer earn their place deep near the nerve and for high-risk patients, where they can save a nerve, a root canal and a great deal of money.
Dr Yudelman closes by saying that the smartest dentistry is the quiet dentistry that lasts. Next week: laser dentistry.
Further Resources
How to Spot Dental Upselling (Episode 129, production dentistry): https://optismile.co.za/blog/how-to-spot-dental-upselling/
Root Canal Treatment at OptiSmile: https://optismile.co.za/dental-solutions/root-canal-treatment-cape-town/
Restorative Dentistry at OptiSmile: https://optismile.co.za/dental-solutions/restorative-dentistry/
Dental Bonding at OptiSmile: https://optismile.co.za/dental-solutions/dental-bonding/
Injection Moulding Technique at OptiSmile: https://optismile.co.za/dental-solutions/injection-moulding-technique/
Dental Inlays and Onlays at OptiSmile: https://optismile.co.za/dental-solutions/dental-inlays-overlays/
Paediatric Dentist at OptiSmile: https://optismile.co.za/dental-solutions/paediatric-dentist/
GC (makers of G-ænial and Fuji): https://www.gc.dental/
Cochrane: https://www.cochrane.org/
OptiSmile Podcast Series: https://optismile.co.za/podcasts/
OptiSmile YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@OptismileZa-dentist-cape-town
Contact OptiSmile: https://optismile.co.za/contact-dentist-cape-town/
Disclaimer: The content provided in this podcast, "Save Your Money Save Your Teeth" on Medical Mondays, is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended to serve as dental or medical advice. The insights and opinions expressed by Dr. Clifford Yudelman and any guests are designed to foster a better understanding of dental health, preventive measures, and general well-being, but should not be interpreted as professional dental or medical recommendations. Dr. Clifford Yudelman does not diagnose, treat, or offer prevention strategies for any health conditions directly through this podcast. This platform is not a substitute for the personalized care and advice provided by a licensed dental or healthcare professional. We strongly encourage our listeners to consult with their own dental care providers to address individual dental health needs and concerns. The information shared here aims to empower listeners with knowledge about dental health but must not be used as a basis for making health-related decisions without professional guidance. Your dental care provider is the best source of advice about your dental and overall health. Please always seek the advice of your dentist or other qualified health professionals regarding any questions or concerns about your dental health.
Altri episodi di "eRadio SA"



Non perdere nemmeno un episodio di “eRadio SA”. Iscriviti all'app gratuita GetPodcast.








