
Sarah Carusona has spent 10 years in DTC growth behind brands you already know and love. She's managed over $250M in media and pulled just about every lever in the consumer journey, from loyalty and returns to CRO, data, and inventory. Now she runs BA Commerce, where she embeds senior operators into DTC brands to drive profitable growth that goes way beyond button-pushing on Meta. And she does it all from Buenos Aires!
Highlight Bullets
> Here’s a glimpse of what you would learn….
- Transitioning from Amazon to Shopify for eCommerce brands
- Importance of a compelling brand story and identity
- Strategies for optimizing the consumer journey, including acquisition and retention
- Financial modeling based on customer lifetime value (LTV) and customer acquisition cost (CAC)
- Role of content strategies and authentic storytelling in marketing
- Utilizing influencers and creators for brand promotion
- Team structure and roles focused on acquisition, retention, and conversion
- Balancing lean operations with growth needs in team scaling
- Leveraging AI for data analysis, strategy development, and content creation
- Key takeaways for brand owners considering eCommerce growth strategies
In this episode of the Ecomm Breakthrough Podcast, host Josh Hadley speaks with DTC eCommerce expert Sarah Carusona about transitioning brands from Amazon to Shopify. Sarah shares her journey from dance to digital marketing, and her experience managing nine-figure brands. She explains that successful transitions require a compelling brand story, repeat purchase potential, and a clear financial model based on LTV and CAC. Sarah also discusses her agency B.A. Commerce, which embeds growth operators directly into brands, and highlights the importance of authentic content, integrated team structures covering acquisition, retention, and conversion, and leveraging AI for smarter decision-making.
Here are three action items that Josh identified from this episode:
- Define Your Money Model and Customer Journey
- Test Creative Extensively, Starting with Authentic Content
- Build a Team Covering Acquisition, Conversion, and Retention
Timestamps:
00:00:00 Qualities of a Brand Ready for Shopify
Sarah outlines key traits for a successful Amazon-to-Shopify transition, including brand story, content potential, and repeat revenue opportunities.
00:00:48 Podcast Introduction
The official introduction to the E-comm Breakthrough Podcast, outlining its purpose for seven-figure business owners looking to scale.
00:01:01 Introducing Sarah Carusona
Host Josh Hadley introduces guest Sarah Carusona, detailing her extensive experience in DTC growth and managing large media budgets.
00:02:35 Sarah's Background and BA Commerce
Sarah shares her journey from a dance degree to DTC expert and explains the unique "embedded operator" model of her company.
00:08:35 The Challenge of Moving from Amazon to Shopify
Josh and Sarah discuss the difficulties and different skill sets required for brands transitioning from the Amazon marketplace to DTC.
00:08:51 Who Should (and Shouldn't) Move to Shopify
Sarah explains that brands with a strong story and content potential are ideal candidates, while commodity-like products face greater challenges.
00:12:35 The Playbook for a Shopify Launch
Sarah details her strategy, which is based on an LTV-to-CAC model and blending metrics across Amazon and Shopify.
00:16:32 Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) on Meta
A discussion on typical customer acquisition costs on Meta, differentiating between front-end profitable brands and subscription-based models.
00:18:25 Factoring in the Amazon Halo Effect
Sarah explains how to calculate a blended CAC across channels to account for the sales lift on Amazon from DTC advertising.
00:22:18 Driving Traffic to a New Shopify Store
Sarah discusses strategies for generating traffic, emphasizing the power of building an organic presence before scaling with paid ads.
00:24:56 What Content Goes Viral
The most authentic, unpolished, and founder-led content often performs best, along with genuine creator content from brand fans.
00:26:55 Finding and Working with Creators
Sarah advises on building a creator pool through direct, personal outreach rather than relying solely on platforms or agencies.
00:29:05 Structuring Your DTC Team for Growth
Sarah presents a framework for team building based on three core functions: acquisition, retention, and conversion, scaling as you grow.
00:33:45 The Role of AI in E-commerce Growth
Sarah explains how her team uses AI, focusing on data analysis and strategy first, rather than just mass content implementation.
00:36:36 Three Actionable Takeaways
Josh summarizes the episode's key lessons: defining your money model, testing organic creative first, and structuring your core team.
00:40:24 Most Influential Book
Sarah recommends "Crucial Conversations" for its lessons on navigating tough conversations, a critical skill for any business owner.
00:41:21 Favorite AI Tool
Sarah shares that she uses Claude as her personal EA, emphasizing the importance of training it like a team member.
00:43:07 Brand Owner Shout-Out
Sarah gives a shout-out to Brandy from The Fidget Game, praising her passion and business acumen as a founder.
00:44:00 How to Connect with Sarah
Sarah shares the best ways to get in touch with her, including LinkedIn, X (formerly Twitter), and her company website.
Resources mentioned in this episode:
- Josh Hadley on LinkedIn
- eComm Breakthrough Consulting
- eComm Breakthrough Podcast
- Email Josh Hadley: [email protected]
Tools and Websites
"Shopify": "00:00:00"
"Meta": "00:00:00"
"Amazon": "00:00:00"
"BA Commerce": "00:02:49"
"TikTok Shop": "00:08:51"
"Claude (AI Tool)": "00:41:40"
Books
"Crucial Conversations": "00:41:37"
"100 Million Dollar Money Models" by Alex Hormozi: "00:20:25"
Notable People
"Ezra Firestone": "00:01:01"
"Kevin King": "00:01:01"
"Michael E. Gerber": "00:01:01"
"Brandi from The Fidget Game": "00:43:07"
Additional Resources
"Ecomm Breakthrough Podcast Website": "00:44:19"
Episode Sponsor:
This episode is brought to you by eComm Breakthrough Consulting where I help seven-figure e-commerce owners grow to eight figures.
I started my business in 2015 and grew it to an eight-fig...
Altri episodi di "Ecomm Breakthrough"



Non perdere nemmeno un episodio di “Ecomm Breakthrough”. Iscriviti all'app gratuita GetPodcast.








