Story Of My Life (“The Back-Up Plan” S5 EP 18)

Hold up, wait a minute! Rachel is already tired of living her dream? Santana is back, and Shirley MacLaine’s Glee debut!  For the first time, Kevin is stumbling over his words during the recap as he tries to make sense of this episode! Jenna shares her thoughts on the storyline she wasn’t a fan of, plus they both noticed that the lip-syncing and wardrobe choices were pretty off. But there’s still a lot to love, like the incredible Shirley MacLaine stealing every scene she’s in! Let us know if you agree or disagree with Kevin and Jenna’s take on this episode on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Jenna and Kevin are back for a rapid round Q&A!  In this session, we find out who the better kisser is—Artie or Mike Chang! We also learn what props they stole from the set and where they store them, the tribute episode they would have loved to do, and the Tina trivia that has them laughing hysterically! Plus, Kevin talks about getting ready to make his London theatre debut!  For fun clips and more inside scoop, don't forget to follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod! See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Can you handle the heat? It's time for some more Spicy Hot Takes! Jenna and Kevin, joined by Glee writer Telly Kousakis, are back with more fan-submitted hot takes, including one from Artie’s biggest fan, who has major beef with something Kevin said! Plus, the show’s real bully, the forced storyline in season six, and the hot take that made them saying, “Oh damn!!”For fun clips and more inside scoop, don't forget to follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod! See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

It’s all led to this … Rachel Berry is finally making her Broadway debut! Jenna and Kevin break down this pivotal episode, celebrating Lea Michele’s performance as both Rachel and Fanny Brice.Jenna shares what it was like returning to set, stepping into the more ‘adult’ New York setting, and filming without Kevin for the first time. The duo also reflects on how much they’re loving these recent episodes, as Glee hits its stride and fires on all cylinders. But not everything felt the same … Jenna reveals an interesting theory about why she may have enjoyed this episode a little less, while Kevin, watching from the sidelines, had the absolute time of his life! For fun clips and more inside scoop, don't forget to follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

The fan Q&As continue with an OG Gleek, who happens to be a bank teller by day and a theater actor by night!  Jenna and Kevin get blown away when Gleek of the Week Emilee admits the first dance at her wedding was to a Glee tune! She also reveals her go-to Glee song when she needs to work up tears on stage, pitches a Tina storyline that impresses our dynamic duo, and gives her hot take on Marley. For fun clips and more inside scoop, don't forget to follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Get it while it's hot! It's time for another round of juicy, spicy hot takes! Jenna and Kevin, joined by Glee writer Telly Kousakis, go through fan-submitted hot takes that make our trio laugh, gasp, and disagree! Some are so spicy that this 'judge-free' zone becomes a bit judgy ... like when they hear Rachel and Puck should have ended up together? Brittana, the worst relationship EVER? And you gotta hear the voice note that gives Telly the chills, plus so much more! For fun clips and more inside scoop, don't forget to follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod! See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

The gang in New York has sex on the mind … and in Artie's case, he's gotten more than he bargained for!  Jenna and Kevin are back to dissect "Tested" with special guest Telly Kousakis, who brings intel from the writer's room, including what the shift to more adult storylines was like, the thought process behind the music chosen for this episode, and the inspiration for Artie's infamous STD suit! Plus, Kevin reveals the scene he couldn't get through without help and why he was super self-conscious when Taylor Swift, yes the one and only, stopped by the set to say hi!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

It's never too late to discover Glee!  Jenna and Kevin chat with Gleek Shantell, who had never heard of the show until she discovered it on Netflix! She has now watched the show in its entirety over ten times but reveals the one episode she's not a fan of, shares who her favorite characters are, and the song from the show that she thinks is way better than the original! See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

This is not a drill! April Rhodes is here! Kristin Chenoweth, the talented Emmy and Tony Award-winning actress is spreading glee and sunshine on the pod today! She joins Jenna and Kevin to spill about her time on 'Glee,' including sharing what it was like to work with Gwyneth Paltrow, aka Holly Holliday, during the show's 100th episode, the memorable moment from that day she won't forget, and her fun idea for a Glee reboot! Plus, Kristin reveals the flood of emotions that hit her while filming her cameo in the Wicked movie 22 years after first playing Glinda on Broadway, her review of 'Maybe Happy Ending' featuring Darren Criss, and a little scoop on her upcoming show, 'Queen of Versailles!'See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Things are getting real on Glee. Kurt gets attacked, Rachel has to choose between school and her dreams, and Mercedes and Sam are over before they even start?! Jenna is officially calling herself a Gleek! Even though she has some issues with the songs chosen for this unofficial Stephen Sondheim tribute episode! Kevin relates to Rachel quitting NYADA and shares a story about failing a semester of classes because of Glee! The duo also share their thoughts on the cringey Samcedes scenes, getting emotional over Kurt's storyline, and Kevin gets the scoop from Amber Riley about the original song "Colorblind." See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.