Ideas Are Not Art
Well, hello there, friend—Understory Bard here, Wade Skalsky. Today's a painful one, and a personal failing, on the creative side, the business side, and in my personal life: the problem of ideas and first drafts. First swings at things.I'm an idea machine. I see patterns, I can roll into a problem and invent a fix, and I always thought I'd make a good consultant—like a friend who (McKinsey or PwC, he couldn't remember which) would spend four or five months in some awesome city, fix whatever they had, then roll out and vacation until the money ran out. Seemed pretty cool when I was young. As an older wiser man, I kind of dig sitting in the garage bunker, sipping coffee, thinking about narwhals. I've got a wife and kids. Being gone six months a year, drinking my face off, is not a recipe for relationship success.The weakness in that strength: I got dopamine from the idea itself. First draft of a novel, a song, a haiku, a poem—boom, I created something, got paid internally, and moved on. The dirty little secret bohemian creative people don't want you to know is that that's not art. An idea is something, but you don't own it until you craft something from it. You're not entitled to an idea just because you had it. Comedians come up with the same joke independently all the time; there's no ownership in the idea. You can own how you tell it, and where it sits in the set, and that comes with the work. Same in business. I've started so many businesses and been in so many partnerships, then decided it must not work because nothing was happening fast enough.Tony Robbins—whether you're a fan or not, I read a couple of his books when I was younger, and they were kind of helpful—has a quote that's true: people overestimate what they can do in a year and underestimate what they can do in a decade, because they don't understand compounding effort. Things start small. (Yes, I dragged the rule of 72 into it. I was told there was no math today.) Very few people come out of the gate as an overnight success. The book I'm writing now, my Sojourner novel, is for sure over 50,000 words into the first draft—maybe 60,000, I'm not sure. Even if it went huge, it wouldn't be overnight, and it wouldn't be the next Harry Potter (there's cursing in it, and it's not a kids' book). I'm in my 50s. I've written novels before. I've done all sorts of creative things, and business things that worked and didn't. All of that compounded effort is going into this book. If it succeeds, that's why.Creatives overvalue ideas and first drafts. A first draft is a skeleton. Everything in it is a placeholder—you're setting a table, and you may take the centerpiece out, or the candles, and not replace them. Execution is where art is truly made. Coming up with ideas is easy. Any moron can come up with a good idea. Execution is what separates the successful from the unsuccessful, the master from the amateur, and the happy from the unhappy. The only people less happy than the frustrated artist, I think, are the very verbally smart people who aren't successful, because they mistake topical intelligence and an ability to communicate for an ability to be successful. I've done that. I'm smart, but I'm not a genius, and I'm a complete moron in some of the areas you actually need if you want to be rich. I was willfully blind to those gaps. Getting paid by my ideas internally led to unhappiness. You can auger in and say it's everyone else's fault, or you can take some responsibility.So that's the thought for today: your ideas and your first drafts are just placeholders. They're not art. They're barely something. Realize that, and a whole other game opens—a whole other realm of possibility. That can be exciting, if you let it be.Part of me wants the Sojourner first draft done. Part of me really doesn't, because I know that's when the actual work begins: buckle down and make it into something I can be proud of. The old me would have sent the rough draft out, been told it was a little rough, decided they didn't know what they were talking about, self-published it, and it would have sucked and nobody would have read it. The new me, the older distinguished gentleman, is not doing that. If you're younger, and you were like I was, you can save yourself twenty years of "why isn't this working"—and the conversation with your wife: why aren't you doing better, you're so smart. Thankfully we don't have that conversation anymore. I've had that experience. Zero of ten. Do not recommend.From the garage bunker, we will talk again.