Bonus Episode: Men are not Angels
The video Jake responds to: Nick Freitas and Christian Heiens on *Making the Argument*, Ep. 624, [”A Generation Was Told He Was The Villain. They Don’t Believe It.”]📚 The sources Jake reads from (Bookshop.org links support independent bookstores and this podcast):- The Federalist Papers (Signet Classics, ed. Charles R. Kesler) - Plato, The Republic (Dover Thrift, Benjamin Jowett translation)⭐ Support the podcast with a paid subscription: Subscribe hereSome people online have been arguing that because the Jedi were bad at certain things, the Empire must have been the good guys. In this Lessons from History bonus episode, I answer that almost entirely with quotes from the Federalist Papers, the Bible, and Plato’s Republic, along with James Madison, John Adams, the Declaration of Independence, and the Massachusetts Constitution of 1780. I go through eight pro-Empire arguments, then the real failures of the Jedi. The answer is the one Madison gave in Federalist No. 51: men are not angels. Jedi bad does not mean Empire good. Neither a single ruler nor a small group of guardians can be trusted with all the power, and no government can save a people who lack virtue. That has to start in our own homes.“If men were angels, no government would be necessary.” (James Madison, Federalist No. 51)As a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.Free online texts:Federalist Papers (Avalon Project, Yale Law School): https://avalon.law.yale.edu/subject_menus/fed.aspDeclaration of Independence (Avalon Project): https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/declare.aspMassachusetts Constitution of 1780: https://malegislature.gov/Laws/ConstitutionPlato’s Republic, Jowett translation (Project Gutenberg): https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/1497James Madison, Virginia Ratifying Convention, June 20, 1788: https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-11-02-0101John Adams to the Massachusetts Militia, Oct. 11, 1798: https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Adams/99-02-02-3102John Adams to Mercy Otis Warren, Apr. 16, 1776: https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Adams/06-04-02-0044John Adams, Autobiography, June 2, 1778: https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Adams/01-04-02-0001-0094Chapters:00:00 Hook: “If men were angels” (Federalist No. 51)00:28 Intro00:39 Welcome00:57 Lessons from History: the Jedi vs. the Empire debate03:24 The answer: men are not angels03:44 1. “The Republic couldn’t get anything done”06:19 2. “A dictator who makes it work”08:25 3. “Palpatine diagnosed a real problem”10:48 4. “The brutality was necessary”16:51 5. “The rebellion brings chaos”18:39 6. “The Empire is a meritocracy”20:46 7. “The Empire brought law to the Outer Rim”22:25 8. “Jedi bad means Empire good”24:31 The Jedi were wrong too: philosopher kings26:04 Watchdogs, a clone army, and the family27:58 Anakin, education, and formation29:21 Passion: constraint, not annihilation30:05 Virtue starts in the family34:00 Against all enemies: you cannot win a surrender34:49 Persuasion, not force35:28 The Declaration: a long train of abuses36:20 A government of laws, not of men37:46 ClosingWisdom in the Best Books and Films: bite-sized nuggets of truth from great books and films, used to help us become better people. Hosted by Jake Bair.Read or listen on Substack: https://wisdominbestbooks.substack.com⭐ Paid subscription: https://wisdominbestbooks.substack.com/subscribeQuestions, recommendations, or comments: [email protected] you enjoyed this, please subscribe and share it with someone who’d like it.## TagsMen Are Not Angels, Star Wars, Jedi, Empire, Sith, Palpatine, Anakin Skywalker, Jedi vs Empire, was the Empire the good guy, Federalist Papers, Federalist 51, James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, John Adams, Plato, The Republic, philosopher kings, King James Bible, 1 Samuel 8, Declaration of Independence, Massachusetts Constitution, government of laws not of men, checks and balances, virtue, Nick Freitas, Making the Argument, Christian Heiens, Lessons from History, bonus episode, Wisdom in the Best Books and Films Get full access to Wisdom in the Best Books and Films at wisdominbestbooks.substack.com/subscribe