Is Airbnb Worth It? What Happens When Your Short-Term Rental Fails?
Is Airbnb Worth It? What Happens When Your Short-Term Rental Fails? You bought a rental property because someone told you it could generate $3,000 per month on Airbnb. But what happens when the bookings don't come in, the expenses pile up, and you discover that the property doesn't even cash flow as a traditional rental? That's the situation facing a listener who contacted Wayne and Gabby Hillier for advice. On today's Canadian Real Estate Investing Morning Show, Wayne and Gabby examine the realities of Airbnb and short-term rental investing, including the additional management responsibilities, inconsistent revenue, regulatory risks, and the importance of having an alternative strategy when things don't go according to plan. They also explain why they've never pursued short-term rentals themselves, despite recognizing that they can be successful businesses when operated properly. And most importantly, they answer the listener's question: What should you do when your Airbnb investment isn't working? The Listener's Airbnb Nightmare The episode begins with a listener describing a frustrating investment experience. They purchased a house after hearing that it could generate more than $3,000 per month through Airbnb. Unfortunately, the actual experience has been very different. The property is barely generating enough revenue to cover its monthly payments, and operating the short-term rental has become a nightmare. Making matters worse, the property doesn't generate positive cash flow when evaluated as a conventional long-term rental. The investor now feels trapped between operating a business they don't enjoy and owning a property that doesn't perform financially as a traditional investment. Wayne and Gabby explain why this situation illustrates the importance of understanding the investment before purchasing it. Why Airbnb Is a Different Business From Traditional Real Estate Investing Wayne makes an important distinction between operating short-term accommodations and owning conventional rental properties. A traditional buy-and-hold investor generally purchases a property with the intention of generating rental income, paying down the mortgage, and benefiting from potential long-term appreciation. A short-term rental operator may prioritize something entirely different. The property's nightly rate, occupancy, location, amenities, and guest experience can be more important to the operating business than the property's performance as a traditional rental. Wayne compares the model to operating a small hotel. A property might generate substantial short-term rental revenue while being a relatively poor conventional real estate investment. That doesn't automatically make it a bad business. But it does mean investors need to understand which business they're actually entering. Why Wayne and Gabby Have Never Invested in Airbnb Wayne and Gabby explain that they have never operated short-term rental properties. Their decision isn't based on believing the business model cannot work. They recognize that successful operators can build profitable businesses, particularly when they develop strong systems and operate at scale. However, short-term rentals don't align particularly well with the Five Fundamentals that guide Wayne and Gabby's long-term real estate investment strategy. They prefer properties that generate reliable cash flow, attract suitable long-term tenants, offer reasonable appreciation potential, and remain financially sustainable through changing market conditions. They also value the ability to operate a relatively low-maintenance rental portfolio using established property management systems. Short-term accommodations would require building and operating a substantially different business. For Wayne and Gabby, the additional work and potential returns haven't justified making that change. A Successful Airbnb Doesn't Always Mean a Good Property Investment Wayne explains that some investors purchase properties primarily because they expect the short-term rental business to perform well. They may choose a condominium with an attractive view, a property with luxury amenities, or a destination rental specifically designed around an appealing guest experience. Those features can support a successful hospitality business. But the underlying property may have limited appreciation potential, significant carrying costs, or relatively poor performance as a long-term rental. The important distinction is that short-term operating profits and long-term real estate investment quality should be evaluated separately. Ideally, an investor should understand both. What Happens if Airbnb Is No Longer an Option? One of the biggest concerns involves changing regulations and condominium bylaws. A live listener shares an experience involving a potential Airbnb condominium purchase in Sylvan Lake. After receiving an accepted offer, the buyer discovered during the condominium document review that short-term rentals were prohibited. The restriction ended the deal. Wayne explains why this is an important risk for investors purchasing condominiums for Airbnb. Even when short-term rentals are permitted at the time of purchase, condominium rules may change. Municipal restrictions, licensing requirements, or other operating conditions can also affect the business. If the property only works financially as a short-term rental, losing that option may leave the investor with a financially difficult asset. Why Every Airbnb Investment Needs a Backup Plan Gabby argues that an investor should evaluate whether a potential short-term rental could also work as a conventional long-term rental. If Airbnb bookings decline, government restrictions change, or the owner decides the business requires too much time, there should ideally be another financially viable use for the property. This provides more flexibility. The listener's biggest problem is that they don't have that alternative. Their property doesn't cash flow as a long-term rental. As a result, they have fewer options when the short-term rental business underperforms. Wayne and Gabby emphasize the importance of considering this scenario before purchasing a property. Short-Term Rentals Are Not Passive Income Another major discussion concerns the amount of work required to operate an Airbnb. Gabby explains that traditional rental property management already involves screening tenants, coordinating repairs, handling maintenance requests, and managing vacancies. But short-term rentals can require far more frequent activity. Instead of managing one tenant over a 12-month lease, an Airbnb operator might deal with dozens or hundreds of different guests throughout the year. Each booking creates another turnover. That means coordinating cleaning, communicating check-in instructions, restocking supplies, inspecting the property, managing reviews, and ensuring the unit is ready for the next guest. Wayne questions whether the additional revenue is worth the extra responsibility. An Airbnb that appears to generate a few hundred dollars more each month than a traditional rental may not offer sufficient additional compensation for the time and operating costs involved. Why $3,000 in Airbnb Revenue Doesn't Tell the Whole Story One of the biggest mistakes investors can make is assuming that projected nightly rates will translate into consistent monthly revenue. Just because a property could generate $3,000 in a strong month doesn't mean it will produce that amount every month. Occupancy changes. Travel demand changes. Seasons change. And not every available night will necessarily be booked. An investor also needs to account for cleaning, supplies, platform fees, utilities, maintenance, insurance, furnishing, and the time required to operate the business. Wayne and Gabby explain why investors need to evaluate realistic operating profits rather than relying on optimistic revenue projections. Gabby's Experience With Hotel Revenue Management Gabby shares an interesting perspective from her career before becoming a full-time real estate investor. She previously worked in revenue management for three hotels. Her responsibilities included forecasting occupancy, setting room rates, monitoring demand, and adjusting pricing around seasonal trends and local events. She explains that hotels experience significant variations in occupancy. Some periods are extremely busy. Others are surprisingly quiet. Short-term rental operators face similar challenges. Successful revenue management requires understanding market conditions, seasonal demand, local events, and competitive pricing. For investors who are unfamiliar with hospitality operations, these responsibilities can be more complicated than expected. Airbnb vs Hotels: The Customer Experience Wayne and Gabby also discuss their personal experiences as travellers. Wayne expresses frustration with short-term rental cleaning fees and checkout requirements. He questions why some properties charge substantial cleaning fees while still asking guests to complete extensive cleaning tasks before departure. For certain travellers, hotels may offer a simpler alternative. Gabby notes that short-term rentals can still be very appealing when they offer a unique location, extra space, or a distinctive experience. This leads to a discussion about destination properties and the importance of giving guests a compelling reason to choose a short-term rental over a conventional hotel. Destination Rentals vs Everyday Accommodation Gabby explains why she naturally associates short-term rentals with vacation destinations. A property near a beach, mountain resort, or major attraction may offer an experience that isn't easily replicated by a traditional hotel. Wayne agrees that destination-specific properties can support successful hospitality businesses. However, he questions the attractiveness of certain short-term rental strategies in cities where guests have plenty of hotel alternatives. The discussion reinforces why investors need to understand the type of traveller they're targeting and what makes their property competitive. What Should the Struggling Airbnb Investor Do? Wayne eventually returns to the listener's central question. His initial recommendation is straightforward. If the Airbnb business isn't working, the owner no longer wants to operate it, and the property doesn't perform as a long-term rental, selling may be the most sensible option. Wayne acknowledges that this could mean accepting a financial loss. But continuing to operate an unprofitable, time-consuming business simply to avoid recognizing a previous mistake may create even larger problems. The investor needs to compare the financial consequences of selling against the ongoing costs and responsibilities of keeping the property. Wayne encourages the listener to focus on the best decision available today rather than becoming trapped by the original purchase decision. Should They Sell Now or Wait Until Spring? Although Wayne initially recommends selling, he also discusses why timing matters. November is typically a quieter period in many Canadian real estate sales markets. Buyer activity often increases during the spring. Wayne explains that March and April can provide opportunities to reach buyers before the market becomes crowded with additional listings. However, the actual market conditions in spring 2027 are not yet known. He encourages investors to watch changes in listings, buyer activity, and local market conditions throughout the winter. If selling immediately would create a much larger loss, the investor may want to consider whether temporarily holding the property makes financial sense. That decision depends on the cost of carrying the property and the realistic potential benefit of waiting. Could a Long-Term Tenant Be a Temporary Solution? Gabby suggests another option. If managing the Airbnb is the main source of frustration, the investor might consider renting the property to a long-term tenant while preparing for a future sale. That could reduce the daily management responsibilities associated with short-term rentals. However, because the property doesn't cash flow as a conventional rental, the owner would still need to cover the monthly shortfall. This would only make sense if the financial cost of holding the property is manageable and the investor has a realistic exit plan. Understanding Seasonal Real Estate Market Trends Wayne also explains how he monitors changes in the real estate market throughout the year. He begins watching early indicators in November and continues following market activity through December, January, and February. By examining listing inventory, sales activity, and other trends, he attempts to assess the likely strength of the upcoming spring market. Wayne emphasizes that investors should understand seasonal patterns rather than assuming every spring will produce the same conditions. He also discusses why quieter buying seasons can create opportunities for investors seeking favourable purchase prices. Additional Listener Questions The episode also includes a discussion about renting an unfinished basement as a separate storage space. Wayne and Gabby consider whether that arrangement could provide additional income. Gabby raises concerns about insurance requirements, access, and whether the arrangement would be financially worthwhile. Wayne encourages the listener to speak with an insurance broker before pursuing the idea. Another listener shares progress on a potential BRRRR investment in Red Deer, providing an encouraging example of investors actively finding opportunities. REI Masters Costa Rica Retreat Update Wayne and Gabby briefly discuss the REI Masters Costa Rica Retreat, scheduled for January 16 to 20, 2027, near Playa Negra. Participants are finalizing flights and planning their travel. The retreat will combine real estate investing education, goal setting, strategy development, and time with a community of Canadian investors. Interested participants can contact REI Masters to inquire about remaining opportunities. Email: [email protected] Key Takeaways Airbnb and traditional long-term rentals are different operating businesses. Strong short-term rental revenue doesn't necessarily mean the underlying property is a good investment. Short-term rentals require more active management than many beginners expect. Occupancy, cleaning expenses, platform fees, and seasonality influence profitability. Condominium bylaws and municipal regulations can affect short-term rental operations. Investors should understand whether the property has a viable alternative use. A property that only works financially under optimistic Airbnb assumptions carries additional risk. Sometimes selling an unsuccessful investment is better than continuing to lose money. The timing of a sale should be evaluated against ongoing carrying costs. A temporary long-term tenancy may be an option when an investor needs time to exit. Past investment decisions cannot be changed, but future decisions can be improved. About the Canadian Real Estate Investing Morning Show Join real estate investing coaches Wayne and Gabby Hillier every weekday morning at 7:00 AM Mountain Time. The Canadian Real Estate Investing Morning Show provides free real estate investing education, practical strategies, and real-world insights for investors across Canada. Whether you're purchasing your first rental property, managing an established portfolio, or exploring advanced investment strategies, Wayne and Gabby share lessons from their own experiences to help you make informed decisions. REI Masters Mentorship Program Want to be personally coached by Wayne and Gabby? The REI Masters Mentorship Program provides: Weekly live coaching every Monday at 7:00 PM Mountain Time One-on-one investment strategy sessions Access to the Masters Vault educational library A private community of Canadian real estate investors Training covering BRRRR, seller financing, Agreements for Sale, joint ventures, financing, and rental property management Help evaluating deals, understanding cash flow, and managing investment risk Ongoing coaching, accountability, and support Learn more or book a discovery call: https://www.reimasters.ca Our Sponsors Calvin Realty Investor-focused real estate services for Canadian property investors. https://calvinrealty.ca Finngo Bookkeeping & Tax Specialized bookkeeping and tax services for Canadian real estate investors. https://finngo.com/rei Kirkwood & Brennan Mortgage Group Investor-focused mortgage financing and portfolio planning. https://kbmortgages.ca [email protected] Join the Conversation Watch Wayne and Gabby live every weekday morning at 7:00 AM Mountain Time on YouTube. Bring your questions, share your experiences, and join the conversation with investors from across Canada. This episode shares the hosts' opinions and general educational information. They have not personally operated an Airbnb business. Short-term rental performance, regulations, and ownership expenses vary by property and market. Consult appropriately qualified professionals before making investment decisions.